Post by dolans on Jun 8, 2014 7:44:08 GMT -5
Hey folks
First I am no programer. To me, Java is an island , so I have no idea what's possible and what's not. I am a histroy amd geography fanatic, therefore these ideas aim to improve the game to become more like the real course of history.
Enlightenment:; 1604
Industrialisation: Not sure if any state (BDB or SWI) should start with factories. Actually I think you may have forgotten to delete the factories from the great campaign, since Switzerland has the same two in 1604.
World Population: Actually in 1600, it was approximately 500 Mio, but your five most populated empires have already 500 Mio individuals (source: wikipedia)
Cherokee: The accepted culture is Cherokee but the ''state'' is only inhabited by Native Americans, although they get converted quickly.
Iroquois: Same for IRO
Spain: Since the discovery of America was in 1492, I reckon the spanish culture should not only be represented in the Caribbean in small percentages, but has actually spread over the whole Spanish Empire by 1604. Unfortunately, the Spanish were very belligerent with the Natives.
Portugal: The Portuguese ''Diaspora'' is better done. Take it as an example for the Spanish
Algeria: Has a population of zero in 1604
Empire: 1714
World Population: Actually slightly less than 500 Mio, it has not changed much, but your six most populated empires have more than 500 Mio people.
Industry: Still, SWI and a few German states have factories.
Relationships: Most of them seem to be missing.
Spanish Empire: Still almost no Spanish in South America. I think some peple must have emigrated, although most people emigrated later in the victorian era.
WW 2
World Population: 1927: 2 Bio, 1960: 3 Bio I suppose, it should be 2.5 Bio, your 2 Bio is quite close, so it's no big deal
Technology: Tech tree is too advanced e.g. Keynesianism was established after WW 2 in Western states. Furthermore: post_colonialism: was ''discovered'' after the cataclysmic destructi of WW2 so nobody should already have this tech.
highways (limited Acces Roads):
USA, Germany, Italy, Netherlands had already built their highways before WW2 but Austria and Poland got their Autobahns from the Germans whilst occupied. Obviously all the other country didn't have
Autobahns neither.
Germany: estimated population in 1993: 69.314.000 (source: wikipedia) In your scenario Germany has 40 Mio inhabitants
NCN: China lacks army, industry and prestige, so Japan is always very likely to win.
Cold War Era: 1946
World Population: Actually 1950: 2.5 Bio, you have slightly less, so no big deal
Germany: Population in 1950 DDR: 18 Mio BRD: 50 Mio not 17 Mio, BRD has not less people than DDR (source: pdwb.de)
USA: Releasable South Korea becomes ''kingdom os seoul'', although it should be a democratic government or later a presidential dictatorship (source: wikipedia)
Kingdom of Seoul: Too much prestige after release (it had 801 points), became 5th greatest power instantly. This seems very unrealistic.
North Korea: It has no cores on provinces that actually belong to NK. USSR cannot event release NK
China: The Republic of China wins war against communist China in the north of the country.
Actually, in the beginning of the chinese civil war, the troop ratio NCN: CHI was 4 Mio: 1 Mio (1945) at the end it was 1 Mio: 4 Mio (1949). (source: wikipedia)
To me it seems impossible to get these numbers with CHI. The Ratio for 1946 is well chosen NCN: CHI 3: 1
But I suggest, to make it more likely that CHI wins, you should improve the CHI-RUS relation , so russia can come into war- in RL they helped Mao Tse-Tung. They were Commies as well. Duh!
Furthermore, NCN had communist pops as well, that didn't support the government under Chiang Kai-Shek. I think, it wouldn't be bad to put communist rebels in NCN China, that help the communist win.
Future Scenario: 2023
Namibia: today's population 2.1 Mio in 2011 (source: wikipedia)2011
growth rate 0.87% per year
expected population in 2023: 2.1*1.0087^12= 2.33 Mio
your population is about 1 Mio
Namibia is since it's independency in 1990 a stable democracy, no dictatorship (source: wikipedia)
Tech tree: Your placeholder 2 in economic thought and critique must become Neoliberal Economy: it will give -1% factory input as well, and inventions could be Jack Welch as well as Margareth Thatcher and Ronald Reagan, who have had bic influence on economy in 1980. Activation date shuld be in 1980
There will come more...
Questions and Suggestions
You could implement AIDS as an event , like a growth minimizing status. The HI-Virus was discovered in 1930 in central Africa but it ''invaded'' the world mostly in the eighties and ninethies. Is this possible?
Im not sur if third world countries should have all the techs first world countries have in today's and future scenario. But you can't take away e.g. Limited Acess Roads or Great war Experience. I d'suggest to add even more 20 Centuriy-techs to enlarge the gap between first and third world countries, is this possible.
I thing lowering the population in earlier scenarios to the realistic 500 Mio (1604,1714) would slow down pre-victorian industrialisation, is this possible?
In earlier scenarios today's countries like North Korea and South Korea and many mor have no cores on their lands. Can they even be formed when you start in earlier scenarios?
Can I have a List of all your country tags?
Some of my Events don't show text. It just says, Event(Number), and i can read the consequences like getting more prestige. Are you going to add text there or have I just moved the folders to a wrong place. If you really have many events without text, I will offer my service to write these texts. It would be a joy.
Thank you for your effort
Greetings
Dolans
First I am no programer. To me, Java is an island , so I have no idea what's possible and what's not. I am a histroy amd geography fanatic, therefore these ideas aim to improve the game to become more like the real course of history.
Enlightenment:; 1604
Industrialisation: Not sure if any state (BDB or SWI) should start with factories. Actually I think you may have forgotten to delete the factories from the great campaign, since Switzerland has the same two in 1604.
World Population: Actually in 1600, it was approximately 500 Mio, but your five most populated empires have already 500 Mio individuals (source: wikipedia)
Cherokee: The accepted culture is Cherokee but the ''state'' is only inhabited by Native Americans, although they get converted quickly.
Iroquois: Same for IRO
Spain: Since the discovery of America was in 1492, I reckon the spanish culture should not only be represented in the Caribbean in small percentages, but has actually spread over the whole Spanish Empire by 1604. Unfortunately, the Spanish were very belligerent with the Natives.
Portugal: The Portuguese ''Diaspora'' is better done. Take it as an example for the Spanish
Algeria: Has a population of zero in 1604
Empire: 1714
World Population: Actually slightly less than 500 Mio, it has not changed much, but your six most populated empires have more than 500 Mio people.
Industry: Still, SWI and a few German states have factories.
Relationships: Most of them seem to be missing.
Spanish Empire: Still almost no Spanish in South America. I think some peple must have emigrated, although most people emigrated later in the victorian era.
WW 2
World Population: 1927: 2 Bio, 1960: 3 Bio I suppose, it should be 2.5 Bio, your 2 Bio is quite close, so it's no big deal
Technology: Tech tree is too advanced e.g. Keynesianism was established after WW 2 in Western states. Furthermore: post_colonialism: was ''discovered'' after the cataclysmic destructi of WW2 so nobody should already have this tech.
highways (limited Acces Roads):
USA, Germany, Italy, Netherlands had already built their highways before WW2 but Austria and Poland got their Autobahns from the Germans whilst occupied. Obviously all the other country didn't have
Autobahns neither.
Germany: estimated population in 1993: 69.314.000 (source: wikipedia) In your scenario Germany has 40 Mio inhabitants
NCN: China lacks army, industry and prestige, so Japan is always very likely to win.
Cold War Era: 1946
World Population: Actually 1950: 2.5 Bio, you have slightly less, so no big deal
Germany: Population in 1950 DDR: 18 Mio BRD: 50 Mio not 17 Mio, BRD has not less people than DDR (source: pdwb.de)
USA: Releasable South Korea becomes ''kingdom os seoul'', although it should be a democratic government or later a presidential dictatorship (source: wikipedia)
Kingdom of Seoul: Too much prestige after release (it had 801 points), became 5th greatest power instantly. This seems very unrealistic.
North Korea: It has no cores on provinces that actually belong to NK. USSR cannot event release NK
China: The Republic of China wins war against communist China in the north of the country.
Actually, in the beginning of the chinese civil war, the troop ratio NCN: CHI was 4 Mio: 1 Mio (1945) at the end it was 1 Mio: 4 Mio (1949). (source: wikipedia)
To me it seems impossible to get these numbers with CHI. The Ratio for 1946 is well chosen NCN: CHI 3: 1
But I suggest, to make it more likely that CHI wins, you should improve the CHI-RUS relation , so russia can come into war- in RL they helped Mao Tse-Tung. They were Commies as well. Duh!
Furthermore, NCN had communist pops as well, that didn't support the government under Chiang Kai-Shek. I think, it wouldn't be bad to put communist rebels in NCN China, that help the communist win.
Future Scenario: 2023
Namibia: today's population 2.1 Mio in 2011 (source: wikipedia)2011
growth rate 0.87% per year
expected population in 2023: 2.1*1.0087^12= 2.33 Mio
your population is about 1 Mio
Namibia is since it's independency in 1990 a stable democracy, no dictatorship (source: wikipedia)
Tech tree: Your placeholder 2 in economic thought and critique must become Neoliberal Economy: it will give -1% factory input as well, and inventions could be Jack Welch as well as Margareth Thatcher and Ronald Reagan, who have had bic influence on economy in 1980. Activation date shuld be in 1980
There will come more...
Questions and Suggestions
You could implement AIDS as an event , like a growth minimizing status. The HI-Virus was discovered in 1930 in central Africa but it ''invaded'' the world mostly in the eighties and ninethies. Is this possible?
Im not sur if third world countries should have all the techs first world countries have in today's and future scenario. But you can't take away e.g. Limited Acess Roads or Great war Experience. I d'suggest to add even more 20 Centuriy-techs to enlarge the gap between first and third world countries, is this possible.
I thing lowering the population in earlier scenarios to the realistic 500 Mio (1604,1714) would slow down pre-victorian industrialisation, is this possible?
In earlier scenarios today's countries like North Korea and South Korea and many mor have no cores on their lands. Can they even be formed when you start in earlier scenarios?
Can I have a List of all your country tags?
Some of my Events don't show text. It just says, Event(Number), and i can read the consequences like getting more prestige. Are you going to add text there or have I just moved the folders to a wrong place. If you really have many events without text, I will offer my service to write these texts. It would be a joy.
Thank you for your effort
Greetings
Dolans